This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

A president told her leadership team that she wanted more initiative.

She was tired of hearing about opportunities after a competitor had moved first. She wanted people to bring unformed ideas, early questions, and possibilities that had not yet found a place on the annual plan.

At the next leadership meeting, a vice president mentioned an emerging partnership opportunity.

“It is early,” he said. “But there may be a way to work with this group before they become more established.”

The president asked for a market analysis, a revenue model, a legal review, a full implementation plan, and a list of risks. Her questions were reasonable. The organization had limited resources. She did not want the team chasing every interesting idea.

The vice president returned three weeks later with a polished deck. By then, the partnership opportunity had changed. Another company had approached first.

The president was frustrated. “Why did no one bring this to me earlier?”

They had.

The issue was not that she asked hard questions. Leaders should ask hard questions. The issue was that the first response to early thinking had turned a possibility into a performance test. Her team learned that an incomplete idea was expensive to bring forward. The next time they saw a possibility, they waited until they could defend every part of it.

By then, the chance to shape the idea had often passed.

Evaluation apprehension is the concern people feel when they expect their contribution to be judged. In a senior team, that concern can silence early thinking before anyone decides to stay quiet. People bring what they can defend. They hold back what is preliminary, uncertain, or still forming.

This is a problem for leaders who value initiative. The organization may be full of people who notice opportunities. If they believe an idea needs a complete business case before it earns attention, the leadership team will see only what has already survived a private process of self-censorship.

The president wanted more initiative. Her response was training the team to bring less of it.

There is a useful distinction here. A leader can receive an early idea without approving it. Receiving means giving the idea enough space to be examined. Approval comes later, when the evidence is stronger and the tradeoffs are clearer.

Before your next strategy discussion, try this question when someone brings an incomplete idea:

What would help us learn about this before we decide whether to commit to it?

The question changes the task. The person is no longer required to prove the whole idea in the first conversation. The room can decide what would make it worth a second conversation.

That question opens the door. The harder work is building a response your team can trust, so that early thinking reaches you while there is still time to shape it.

In the paid edition below, I walk through the Early Signal Check, a four-step method for receiving an incomplete idea without approving it too soon or dismissing it too early. It covers how to recognize what stage an idea is in, how to receive before you evaluate, how to choose the smallest useful learning step, and how to close the loop so your team keeps bringing you what they notice.

logo

Subscribe to Executive Rounds Paid to read the rest.

Become a paying subscriber of Executive Rounds Paid to get access to this post and other subscriber-only content.

Upgrade

Already a subscriber? Sign in

A subscription gets you:

  • Full weekly premium essays, Archive access, Member-only writing on leadership under pressure
  • The methods to address the diagnosis are accessible to you.