This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

Consider a leader who was, by every account, the kindest person in the building. His team liked him. Meetings were pleasant. Nobody dreaded his feedback, because there was rarely any hard feedback to dread. He thought this was leadership working well. It was actually a slow problem building in plain sight.

On his team was a genuinely talented senior manager whose work was excellent and whose manner was quietly corrosive. Dismissive in meetings, cutting with juniors, resistant to anyone else's ideas. Everyone saw it. The leader saw it too. And for eight months he said nothing, because raising it felt unkind, and because the manager's results made it easy to defer. By the time he finally acted, two good people had already left, and the team had learned something about him that no values statement could undo: that being difficult carried no cost, and that speaking up was not safe.

Most leaders think of avoidance as something that happens to weak or fearful people. In reality, it is most common in kind ones. The instinct to keep the peace, to not make things awkward, to spare someone discomfort, is a good instinct pointed in the wrong direction. It feels like consideration. Often it is self-protection wearing consideration's clothes.

Here is the distinction that matters. Kindness and avoidance can look identical from the outside, and even from the inside. Both are quiet. Both keep the room comfortable. But over time they do opposite things. Kindness protects the person and the truth at once. Avoidance protects your own comfort at the expense of both. The tell is simple and uncomfortable: real kindness sometimes requires you to say the hard thing. Avoidance never does.

There is a reason this is so hard to catch in yourself. Human beings are wired to preserve social harmony, and the discomfort of confrontation is immediate and vivid, while the cost of silence is delayed and diffuse. So the mind does what it does with all delayed costs. It discounts them. The awkward conversation you would have to have today feels more expensive than the erosion you cannot yet see. That math is almost always wrong, and it is wrong in a predictable direction.

For a leader, the stakes are higher than personal comfort, because your avoidance teaches. Every time a corrosive behavior goes unaddressed, or an underperformer is left uncorrected, the whole team learns what you actually tolerate, whatever your stated values say. Silence is not neutral. It is instruction. You are always training your people in what is acceptable, and avoidance trains them in the wrong things.

So here is one question to catch yourself with this week. The next time you notice yourself deciding not to raise something, ask:

Am I staying quiet to protect them, or to protect myself from the discomfort of saying it?

Answer it honestly. If it is the second, you are not being kind. You are being avoidant, and calling it kindness so you can live with it.

Noticing the avoidance is the first step. Having the conversation well is the harder one, and the one that actually changes things.

In the paid edition below I walk through the Candor Protocol, the method I use to help leaders move from avoidance to a conversation that is both clear and genuinely kind. It covers how to tell your kindness from your avoidance, how to make the deferred cost real enough to act on, and how to say the difficult thing in a way that protects the relationship rather than rupturing it. If you want the method and not only the diagnosis, continue below.

logo

Continue reading with a paid subscription

The full edition of Executive Rounds continues for paid subscribers. Upgrade to keep reading.

Become a paid member

Already a subscriber? Sign in

A paid subscription includes: