This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

Marcus had covered for Dana for eight months.

Missed deadlines got quietly reassigned. A client complaint got smoothed over before it reached anyone above him. When another director asked how Dana's project was tracking, Marcus said "on track" before he had even checked.

He told himself this was loyalty. He had hired Dana. He believed in her. And a good leader does not abandon someone the moment things get hard. He protects them while they find their footing.

That is what Marcus told himself. It was not what the team saw.

At first, nobody said anything. Then the quiet adjustments began.

Priya picked up two of Dana's accounts "just for this sprint," which became three sprints. She absorbed the work without being asked, because that is what high performers do when they see a gap. In a one-on-one, she raised it carefully, not as a complaint but as a question she was not sure she was allowed to ask: "Is this going to keep being the arrangement?"

Marcus said he would look into it. He did not. Looking into it meant having a conversation he did not want to have, and every week that passed made the conversation harder. The cost of the silence was not dramatic. It was cumulative. One person carried the weight. Another was shielded from it. And the rest of the team watched, drawing conclusions that Marcus never intended but could not prevent.

The story the team was quietly telling itself had already changed: effort and results did not seem to matter as much as who the boss had decided to protect.

Priya resigned six weeks later.

In her exit conversation, she did not mention compensation. She did not mention opportunity or title or workload. She said one sentence that Marcus could not explain away:

"I stopped believing that doing good work here actually meant anything."

That is the line that should stop every leader who has ever shielded someone at the team's expense. Priya did not leave because she was overworked. She left because the implicit contract, the one that says performance matters and standards are real, had been quietly broken by the person responsible for upholding it.

What Marcus did not see, and what most leaders in his position do not see, is that his loyalty to Dana was never really about Dana. It was about himself.

There is a pattern that runs underneath this, and it is worth naming precisely. When a leader hires, mentors, or champions someone, that person's success becomes partly the leader's identity. Their failure threatens to become the leader's failure. So the leader shields them, not because shielding is the right thing, but because their struggle has become too personally threatening to face. The loyalty is real. It is also self-protective, and it operates below awareness.

The result is what you saw with Marcus: a leader who genuinely believes he is being loyal while quietly redistributing the cost of one person's underperformance onto everyone who is actually performing. The team reads it instantly. The leader is usually the last to see it, because the story he is telling himself, "I am standing by my people," feels noble enough to survive without examination.

So here is one question to sit with before your next instinct to protect someone on your team.

Am I withholding this feedback for their benefit, or to protect myself from the discomfort of delivering it?

If the honest answer is the latter, you are not being loyal. You are being avoidant, and the people meeting the standard are the ones paying for it.

That question catches the moment. What to do after you catch it, how to hold someone accountable without abandoning them, and how to repair the implicit contract your team has been watching you break, is the harder work.

In the paid edition below I walk through the Loyalty Audit, a method for distinguishing genuine loyalty from self-protective shielding, repairing accountability without severing the relationship, and rebuilding the trust your high performers lost while you were looking the other way. If you want the method and not only the diagnosis, continue below.

logo

Subscribe to Executive Rounds Paid to read the rest.

Become a paying subscriber of Executive Rounds Paid to get access to this post and other subscriber-only content.

Upgrade

Already a subscriber? Sign in

A subscription gets you:

  • Full weekly premium essays, Archive access, Member-only writing on leadership under pressure
  • The methods to address the diagnosis are accessible to you.