This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

A chief executive I once advised was blindsided by a problem that had been building for two months. A major client had been signaling frustration for weeks. Three people in the company knew. By the time it reached her, it arrived as a mild line in a status update, one sentence among twenty, stripped of any urgency. She was not badly informed. She was carefully informed. Everyone who had touched the news, without quite deciding to, had made it a little smaller.

Most leaders assume that the higher they rise, the clearer their view becomes. More reports, more dashboards, more access. In practice the opposite often happens. The higher you sit, the more the information reaching you has been handled on the way up, and handling almost always means smoothing.

This is rarely dishonesty. It is something quieter and more human. Each person who passes news upward makes small, reasonable adjustments. They soften the edge so they do not sound alarmist. They wait for a better moment that never quite comes. They add context that is really reassurance. None of it feels like distortion in the moment. In aggregate, the version that reaches the top is calmer, later, and less actionable than the reality on the ground.

There is a name for the core of this. Psychologists call it the mum effect, the well-documented reluctance people feel to be the one who delivers bad news. Layer that reluctance across every level of a hierarchy and the result is predictable. Bad news travels upward slowly, if it travels at all, and it arrives pre-softened. The more authority you hold, the more layers your information has crossed, and the more it has been edited before you ever see it.

The uncomfortable part is that leaders shape this without meaning to. How you react to unwelcome information the first time teaches everyone around you whether it is safe to bring you more of it. React with visible frustration, or let a messenger pay a price even once, and you will be rewarded with smoother reports and worse surprises. The filter is not only something done to you. It is partly trained by you.

So the real danger is not that you are uninformed. You may be drowning in information. The danger is that the specific information you most need, the early, unwelcome, still-fixable kind, is exactly what the system is best at keeping from you.

Here is one thing you can do this week. Choose one person whose judgment you trust and ask them a single, direct question. What are people not telling me, or telling me too late? Then, and this is the hard part, receive the answer without defending yourself. How much you actually hear, and how carefully they choose their words, will tell you a great deal about what the rest of the system is holding back.

That question opens a crack. Keeping the channel open is the real work.

In the paid edition below I walk through the Clarity Check, the method I use to help leaders find where truth is stalling inside their organization and build channels that let unwelcome information reach them early enough to matter. It covers where bad news gets stuck, how to audit your own reactions so you stop training the filter, and how to make honesty the low-risk choice instead of the costly one. If you want the method and not only the diagnosis, continue below.

logo

Continue reading with a paid subscription

The full edition of Executive Rounds continues for paid subscribers. Upgrade to keep reading.

Become a paid member

Already a subscriber? Sign in

A paid subscription includes: