This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

Thomas opened the pricing meeting the way he always did.

"I have been thinking we need about a 12 percent increase. But I want to hear from everyone."

He meant it. He genuinely wanted their views.

He went around the table. Finance suggested 11 percent. Sales suggested 10. Marketing suggested 13. Operations said 12 seemed about right.

The discussion was thoughtful. The team landed on 12 percent.

Thomas left pleased. The room had validated his thinking.

Six months later, the increase was costing them customers in a segment nobody had discussed.

When he asked his head of sales about it privately, she said something he did not expect.

"Honestly, I came in thinking 5 percent. Once you said 12, I figured you knew something I did not."

Does that surprise you?

It should not. It happens in leadership meetings every day.

Most leaders believe that asking for input after sharing their view still produces honest input.

It usually does not.

There is a name for what happened in Thomas's meeting. Psychologists call it anchoring: the first number or view stated becomes a reference point that everyone else adjusts from, rather than thinking independently.

Anchoring affects everyone, including experts who know about it.

But it becomes much stronger when the anchor comes from the most senior person in the room.

Now two forces are working together. The first view sets the reference point. The source of that view carries authority.

The result is a room that appears to deliberate but mostly circles the leader's starting position.

Notice what this does to the quality of the decision.

You lose the independent perspectives you were trying to gather. You lose the outlier view that might have been correct. And you gain false confidence, because the agreement looks like confirmation.

Thomas did not get four views on pricing. He got his own view, reflected back four times with small variations.

The most valuable person in that meeting was the one who came in at 5 percent. And she never said it.

Here is one practice you can use at your very next meeting.

Before you share your own view on any important decision, ask everyone to write down their answer first.

A number, a recommendation, a single sentence. Collect them, or have people read them aloud, before you say a word.

You will be surprised how often the spread is wider than you expected.

That spread is not disagreement to be managed. It is information you would never have received otherwise.

Writing first protects one meeting. But the anchoring effect of seniority runs through every conversation you have, including the hallway, the one-on-one, and the email thread.

In the paid edition below, I walk through the Speak-Last Sequence, the five-step method I use with leaders to collect independent thinking before their own view shapes it, share their view without ending the conversation, and make it safe for the 5-percent voice to speak.

logo

Subscribe to Executive Rounds Paid to read the rest.

Become a paying subscriber of Executive Rounds Paid to get access to this post and other subscriber-only content.

Upgrade

Already a subscriber? Sign in

A subscription gets you:

  • Full weekly premium essays, Archive access, Member-only writing on leadership under pressure
  • The methods to address the diagnosis are accessible to you.