This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

At 11:40 p.m., Elena knew exactly what to do.

She had been turning the problem over for three weeks. Tonight, alone at the kitchen table, it suddenly felt simple.

The product line was underperforming. The team leading it was slow. The answer was obvious: shut it down, reassign the people, and move on.

She drafted the email to her leadership team before midnight. It was clear, decisive, and well written.

She felt better than she had in days.

Have you ever had that feeling? The relief of finally knowing?

Most leaders recognize it. And most leaders trust it.

That trust is worth examining.

Elena had slept five hours a night for most of the month. She had spent the evening on two investor calls and a difficult conversation with her co-founder.

She was not thinking more clearly at midnight. She was thinking more narrowly.

The certainty she felt was not the product of better analysis. It was the product of a tired mind looking for a place to land.

There is a name for this. I call it impairment blindness: the tendency of a depleted mind to lose accuracy in judging its own condition.

Sleep research has shown it for decades. When people are short on sleep for several nights, their performance keeps declining. Their sense of how impaired they are does not keep pace.

In plain terms, the instrument you would use to detect fatigue is the instrument fatigue damages first.

So you do not feel worse at deciding. You feel fine. Sometimes you feel sharper than usual.

This is why the pattern is so dangerous for leaders.

Exhaustion does not announce itself as doubt. It announces itself as conviction.

The tired leader does not feel confused. The tired leader feels decisive.

And decisiveness is the trait most leaders have been rewarded for since the beginning of their careers.

So the moment when your judgment is most compromised can feel like the moment it is working best.

Think about the last major decision you made late at night, at the end of a hard week, or after a run of bad news.

Did you feel uncertain? Or did you feel, for the first time in a while, that the answer was clear?

If it was the second, that clarity deserves a second look.

Here is one practice you can use this week. Because you cannot trust how rested you feel, stop asking how you feel. Count instead.

Before any consequential decision, count the hours you slept over the past three nights. If the total is under eighteen, treat your certainty as unverified until one other person has read the decision.

The number is not magic. The point is that it is external. It does not depend on the judgment fatigue has already compromised.

If the count is fine, act with confidence.

If it is not, you are not forbidden to decide. You are required to borrow someone else's eyes first.

That single rule will catch a large share of the decisions you would later regret.

But it does not tell you what to do with the certainty itself, or how to tell which decisions need the closest look.

In the paid edition below, I walk through the Certainty Screen, the five-step method I use with leaders to test whether a confident decision is clear thinking or fatigue in disguise. It includes how to sort reversible decisions from irreversible ones, and how to recruit the people who can see your depletion when you cannot.

logo

Subscribe to Executive Rounds Paid to read the rest.

Become a paying subscriber of Executive Rounds Paid to get access to this post and other subscriber-only content.

Upgrade

Already a subscriber? Sign in

A subscription gets you:

  • Full weekly premium essays, Archive access, Member-only writing on leadership under pressure
  • The methods to address the diagnosis are accessible to you.